Climate denier said:
where are all the recording thermometers placed? How accurate? Are they maintained? I’m looking at a Florida sky right now. I don’t see any therometers at any altitude. How about wind speeds? At the very very least give me some estimate of error with these predictions.
I replied:
“Doi! I don’t use thermometers in my work.” I study the redistribution of energy throughout the Earth system. That’s a fundamentally different approach from standing outside and looking for a thermometer in the sky.
You are confusing local weather observations with climate-system analysis. No serious climatologist expects to place a thermometer at every altitude, over every ocean, or in every location. Earth’s climate is monitored through multiple independent observing systems:
• Atmosphere: Weather stations, weather balloons (radiosondes), aircraft, and satellites measure temperature, humidity, atmospheric pressure, wind speed, and circulation patterns.
• Oceans: Thousands of autonomous Argo floats measure temperature and salinity through the upper 2,000 meters of the oceans. Their temperature sensors have an instrumental accuracy of approximately ±0.002°C after appropriate quality control. These are actual measurements, not model projections.
• Earth’s energy balance: Satellites measure incoming solar radiation and outgoing infrared radiation. Ocean observations independently document how much excess energy is accumulating in the oceans.
• Cryosphere: Satellites and field measurements monitor sea ice, ice-sheet mass, glacier retreat, surface albedo, and changes in the Earth’s reflective properties.
Now, let me explain what Sidd Mukherjee, physicist, and I have been researching since 1992.
Our approach is based on **Earth-system energy redistribution and the coupling of climate feedbacks.** We don’t simply look at whether one thermometer went up or down. We examine how energy moves through interconnected physical systems and how changes in one system influence others.
Our Climate Jerk and Coupled Climate Feedback Index work examines six major variables:
1. Cloud cover
2. Surface albedo
3. Sea ice
4. Atmospheric water vapor
5. Ocean heat content
6. Surface temperature
We normalize the historical data, account for the direction of each variable’s warming influence, and examine relationships among the variables. We evaluate 15 pairwise feedback relationships, as well as higher-order combinations, to investigate how these systems interact and whether their relationships are accelerating.
That’s the important distinction: **warming is not an isolated temperature reading. It is an energy imbalance that activates feedbacks, changes circulation, redistributes heat, alters ice and cloud behavior, and amplifies other changes throughout the climate system.**
As for measurement error, it is not one universal number. Every observing system has its own instrumental uncertainty, sampling limitations, calibration requirements, and data-processing uncertainty. Researchers quantify those uncertainties and evaluate them when combining observations. Argo, for example, publishes instrument accuracy and quality-control information. Satellite observations have their own calibration and retrieval uncertainties. Climate projections also have uncertainty ranges associated with emissions scenarios, natural variability, and model structure.
And wind speeds? They are measured using anemometers, ocean buoys, aircraft, weather balloons, and satellite instruments. Wind is important to atmospheric and ocean circulation, heat transport, and energy exchange. But you don’t need to measure every wind gust to establish a global energy imbalance.
Finally, you keep using the word **predictions** as though climate science were about guessing tomorrow’s weather. It isn’t. Climate projections are conditional assessments of how the climate system responds under specified forcing scenarios. Observations establish the changes already occurring; projections assess the risks ahead.
So before demanding that I show you a thermometer in the Florida sky, perhaps take the time to understand what we’re actually measuring.
**The climate system is an interconnected energy system. The evidence comes from multiple independent observing networks, not from whether you can see a thermometer outside your window.**
Read the research before dismissing it.