One way into discussing climate change as a whole is to refer to the water cycle, because most people learned about it at school.
The water cycle is now supercharged by extra heat in the oceans.
Warmer seas produce more evaporation – and that extra water vapour* carries the extra heat high into the air. The water vapour then releases the extra heat into high-altitude air as it condenses to make clouds. So weather systems are becoming more energetic, more chaotic. Like other aspects of the climate systems, the water cycle seems to be creating more extremes – prolonged droughts, and also sudden huge rainfall events.
*7% more water vapour for each extra 1 C degree of average global temperature, so we’ve added about 10% at this point. Changes of state (such as evaporation and condensation) involve lots of heat – in physics this is called latent heat.
Our system gives no value to global commons such as the atmosphere or the oceans, because they are not seen as “scarce commodities”. One oak tree does not matter, because there are vast numbers of oak trees.
Pumping sewage into the sea doesn’t matter, because the sea is too big for it to matter.
Pumping CO2 into the air doesn’t matter, because the air is limitless.*
This is a mythological view of the world, and generally people prefer myths to facts, because facts don’t obey wishes.
*In fact if there was a lift that could travel vertically at the speed of a fast car, within minutes you’d need breathing equipment.
— Rocky Rex
Human CO2 Climate Change: All You Need to Know
An unprecedented rate of Earth-system change.
The Geological Society of London (the UK’s expert association of professional geologists since 1807) says:
” ….the current speed of human-induced CO2 change and warming is nearly without precedent in the entire geological record, with the only known exception being the instantaneous, meteorite-induced event that caused the extinction of non-bird-like dinosaurs 66 million years ago” (H/T Rocky Rex)
We’ve arrived at a very similar observation in our own work, but I don’t think I’ve seen it stated this clearly—or published elsewhere. Thanks, Rocky, for helping to illuminate it.
Juxtapose the two and let me know whether the comparison can be communicated more effectively.
Multiple climate indicators now point to rates of warming-related disruption far beyond those observed during the modern instrumental era.
There is no well-established geological analog for a sustained, multi-variable, decade-scale pattern of accelerating change across the full Earth system at the resolution available in contemporary observations. If sustained, this may represent one of the most abrupt large-scale climate transitions in Earth’s geological history.
Rocky replied:
I’ve been citing that for a long time, and I’m always impressed by how many people can totally ignore it. It’s very much the scientific version of “The Good Ancestor” poem, it should hit people between the eyes and wake them up. All the signs are that we are entering an abrupt climate change process. Have I told you this true story before?
In the mid 1950s, Russell Coope was looking for a PhD project after graduating as a geologist. He noticed beetle remains in ice age deposits in a gravel pit in the UK Midlands. His supervisor, Prof Fred Shotton, said something like: “I expect they are just modern beetles that have got stuck to the surface.” Fred was wrong – a rare event.
Coope decided to base his PhD on recording what kinds of beetles there were in different ice age deposits, to see where it led. He discovered that the mix of beetles was linked to the temperatures at that time.
He did this by comparing his layer-by-layer collections with collections of beetles from different places in the modern world – beetles happen to evolve very slowly, so the actual variety of beetles hasn’t changed much over the last million years or so.
As his research proceeded, Coope was shocked to find that the beetles showed that at times, during the ice ages, temperatures had changed significantly in just a few decades – his beetles showed that the Earth’s climate is not fundamentally stable.
He had discovered abrupt climate change events, a previously unknown phenomenon. Geologists had always assumed that most processes were slow.
I had the good fortune to be a student in Coope’s palaeontology lectures long ago…. and also in Fred’s physical geology lectures. (In 1943, Fred Shotton was involved in a secret project that produced geological maps of certain beaches in northern France…… that’s a movie that should be made by someone)
“We are messing with the trigger that causes climate change….the outcome is likely to be ferocious.”
– Professor Russell Coope (1930-2011)
Russell Coope and his ice age beetles https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMyt-UbcUQo
YOUTUBE.COM
Russell Coope on fossil beetles in the Cromer Forest-bed at Happisburgh, Norfolk, UK
Russel
The Human Induced Climate Change Experiment
The climate system is not simply warming—it is changing how it responds to that warming. Coupled climate feedbacks are becoming one of the most consequential dimensions of climate risk in the 21st century because they amplify changes and connect individual tipping-point pathways into larger cascading effects.
The longer warming persists, the more climate feedbacks become active. As these feedbacks interact, we are already observing nonlinear responses, amplification, and cascading impacts across the climate system. Hundreds of feedback mechanisms have been identified, and many can couple and reinforce one another, contributing to the accelerating pace and increasing magnitude of climate change—The Domino Effect.
by Daniel Brouse, Sidd Mukherjee, and Rocky Rex
Can Anthropogenic Global Warming Be Proven?
Yes.
The isotopic signature of atmospheric carbon dioxide provides direct evidence.
Fossil carbon is depleted in 13C and contains essentially no measurable 14C (radiocarbon), because 14C decays over thousands of years.
Observed atmospheric trends show:
- A measurable decline in the 13C/12C ratio
- A measurable decline in atmospheric 14C concentration
- A measurable decline in atmospheric O2 concentration
These shifts form a remarkably consistent fingerprint.
The carbon isotopes tell us where the additional carbon is coming from. Fossil fuels were formed from ancient biological material and therefore have a characteristic isotopic signature: relatively little 13C and virtually no 14C. As fossil carbon is added to the atmosphere, the atmospheric CO2 isotope ratios shift in precisely the direction expected from fossil-fuel combustion.
The decline in atmospheric oxygen provides an independent piece of evidence.
When fossil fuels are burned, carbon combines with atmospheric oxygen:
C + O2 → CO2
The process consumes O2 and produces CO2. Because the additional atmospheric CO2 is accompanied by a measurable decline in atmospheric O2, the observations are consistent with large-scale combustion of carbon rather than simply a redistribution of carbon through the natural carbon cycle.
This is especially important because the ocean, vegetation, and atmosphere continuously exchange carbon and oxygen. Natural processes can move carbon between reservoirs, but they do not explain the simultaneous long-term pattern of rising CO2, falling O2, declining 13C/12C, and declining radiocarbon.
The four observations reinforce one another:
Rising atmospheric CO2
↓
Declining 13C/12C
↓
Declining 14C
↓
Declining atmospheric O2
Together, these measurements provide a chemical and isotopic fingerprint of fossil-carbon combustion.
Volcanoes do not produce the observed isotopic pattern, and the natural carbon cycle cannot account for the simultaneous changes in the required direction and magnitude.
The molecules carry their own fingerprint—and the atmosphere is preserving the evidence in both carbon and oxygen.
Demand Destruction
THE CLIMATE PROTESTS
by Rocky Rex
“Handcuff the wildfire.
Why should we care about the trees?
What did the birds ever do for us?
Dress the heatwave in an orange jumpsuit.
It is probably a fault in the thermometer anyway.
These scientists – what do they know?
Take the flood to court.
It has no business blocking roads, or sweeping away bridges.
What if an ambulance was stuck on the wrong side of the river?
Give the clouds a suspended sentence.
They are trying to remind us that a warmer world has wetter air. They should go and tell China, not us.
Arrest the rain.
How dare it remind us that the climate is changing?
Let’s pretend it always rained like this.
Sentence the melting ice to 10 years in the cooler.
Why does it matter if the sea floods Bangladesh?
And Miami can be the New Atlantis.
The Earth is protesting?
We are not interested – just lock it up.”
The Good Ancestor
A poem by Daverick Leggett
Every day I walk a hundred years
to the hill where my great, great granddaughter sits.
I carry words of blessing
and reach to touch her back.
But feeling me near she turns,
sad-eyed and heavy with grief.
“What was it like?” she asks,
“when the great whales swam,
when the birds sang you awake,
when the rains came soft,
and the soil smelled sweet underfoot?”
And the blessings
catch in my throat.
On darker days she turns,
her famished face charred, and eyes
sunk in their bony orbits,
burn with curses.
And the blessings
froth at my mouth
with the poisonous
spume of betrayal.
On the darkest of all days
I walk the hundred years
and find no one there.
Let today be the bright day.
Let today be the bright day
I lay my hand upon her back.
And, feeling me near, she turns
and blesses me, saying,
“Your love was fierce enough,
sweet ancestor,
your love was fierce enough.”
About Rocky Rex
I was a science teacher for a long time – and I taught geology when I could. Rocky Rex began as a poster on my lab wall….I was given a T Rex poster, and as soon as I pinned it up I knew he was called Rocky Rex. The name just came to me, out of nowhere.
He gave a focus for information added to his notice board. He ended up making money for school funds by appearing on T-shirts, pens, key-rings etc.
It wasn’t long before some of the other staff started calling me Rocky. This was all long before the internet existed, but when social media appeared it just seemed obvious that my avatar would be Rocky Rex. I like keeping my online stuff slightly disconnected from my offline life. [I actually did a physics degree, but we had to take an “additional science” course in the first year, so I chose geology. It was the same geology course taken by those doing a joint degree in geology and archaeology. ]