Climate Denier Response: Greta Thunberg’s Message

The climate denying Heartland Institute said:
“Everything and everyone we love is at stake.” That’s Greta Thunberg’s message at COP31. The problem? Almost no one is buying it anymore.”

H. Sterling Burnett and Anthony Watts of The Heartland Institute explain why climate alarm has lost its audience

I replied:
No. In fact, the scientific evidence is moving in precisely the opposite direction. More than 99% of the peer-reviewed scientific literature supports the conclusion that human greenhouse-gas emissions are driving modern climate change. So much for Heartland’s claim that nobody is buying it.

Let me explain why this propaganda is particularly offensive to those of us who have spent decades researching the climate system.

Sidd Mukherjee, physicist, and I began publishing our climate research in 1994. At that time, a 4°C global temperature increase over the next several thousand years was considered our high-risk scenario.

Look where we are now.

Based on our evolving analysis of accelerating warming, interconnected climate feedbacks, energy redistribution, and nonlinear climate-system behavior, we have had to continually increase the probability assigned to the most severe scenarios. Our assessment now places a 4°C rise within this century as a serious and increasingly likely outcome—not a distant possibility thousands of years from now.

That is the significance of our Nonlinear Acceleration Hypothesis, Climate Jerk analysis, and integrated climate-feedback and tipping-point network research. We examine how warming activates feedbacks, how those feedbacks become coupled, and how their interactions amplify changes throughout the Earth system.

And why has the risk increased so dramatically? Continued greenhouse-gas emissions, delayed action, and decades of fossil-fuel-backed campaigns to undermine climate science have all contributed to the worsening trajectory.

The scientific community has not abandoned the evidence. The evidence has become more alarming.

Greta Thunberg’s message reflects the reality that our future is at stake. You can ridicule the messenger, dismiss the science, and manufacture the illusion that public opinion determines physical reality. None of that changes the measurements or the underlying physics.

*Shame on you. We have been documenting this progression since 1994. The warnings have become more urgent because the risks have become more serious—not because climate scientists have suddenly become more alarmist.*